In earlier posts, I used generative AI to look for patterns in careers, usually my own: a thematic analysis of an academic career and an attempt to surface patterns in a repository . This time I wanted something more focused: start from a CV, use the iterative questioning approach , and ask the AI to be critical, to help me think about my next move. Why do this? I wanted a fresh pair of eyes, even AI ones. Mid-to-late career, there is a lot of history on a CV, and it is hard to see your own patterns or be properly critical of them. Before applying for anything, I wanted to know whether a type of role, which I will call {X}, actually made sense for me. Stage 1: a generic role, not a job advert Using Claude.ai, I uploaded my CV and started with this: I need to find a ‘golden thread’ running through my CV to build a case for applying for {X}, but essentially who am I? What makes me a good choice? Ask questions one at a time. It very quickly asked for a specific job description. I...
This post was crafted between Claude.ai and me, with Claude acting as a critical co-author: playing devil's advocate and asking me constructive questions, one at a time, until the post was refined. There's a certain irony in a post about feeding one LLM's work into another, then having a third LLM refine it. Two LLMS and a CV What happens if you take one LLM's output and hand it to another to critique and build on? I tried this with ChatGPT and Gemini, using my own academic CV as the test material. This isn't a controlled experiment. It's a technique I tried and what I noticed, and the most interesting result wasn't that one model "won" . Instead, I ended up with two different CVs, each fit for a different purpose. The Experiment & The Prompts I used the paid versions of both ChatGPT and Gemini. I started with my own CV: 27 pages long, as academic CVs tend to be, with a full list of publications. Step 1: the same prompt into both models, with ...